Best of Staten Island: Here are the 5 best pizzerias as voted by our readers

STATEN ISLAND, NY – We have our winners.

Following our coverage of Staten Island’s top five bagel shops, gyms, and yoga studios, we’ve shifted gears to bring you one of the most contested categories in our Best of Staten Island series: Best Pizza.

We asked our readers to tell us which places had the best crust, most elite gravy, and most cheesy pies, and they named 100 – yes, 100 – remarkable spots through hundreds of emails and comments on social networks.

After a week of voting, the first five voters were:

• Rustic pizza and pasteria (97 Lincoln Avenue;; 212-425-2623)

• Staten Island Slice (1880, boulevard Hylan;; 718-524-6522)

• Lorenzo’s Pizza from New York (1910, boulevard Hylan;; 718-979-4700)

• Ungaro charcoal cafe-pizza (1298, avenue Forest;; 646-968-4777)

• Mimmo’s brick oven pizza and trattoria (15 Giffords Ln .;; 718-967-6560)

Over the next two weeks, Advance / will be visiting these pizzerias to show you what makes them fan favorites. Cover will appear on Advance / social media platforms – Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and TIC Tac – as well as in the Staten Island Advance.


Each month will highlight another Best of Staten Island category: August was the bagel shops; September was the gyms / yoga studios; October is pizza; November will be hair salons; and December will end with bakeries.

For each category, there will be a week of nominations, a week of voting and two weeks of focus on the top five winners chosen by our readers.

Top five Best of Staten Island winners to receive coverage on social media platforms Advance / – Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and TIC Tac – and will be featured in the Staten Island Advance.

Want even more food coverage? Join our “Where Staten Island Eats and Drinks” group on Facebook.

Comments are closed.