This Gourmet Pizza Was Named New Jersey’s Best Dessert

We in New Jersey like (rightly) to flex on the quality of our pizza, but this time it’s with a twist.

Brother Bruno’s pizza, deli and bagels in Wayne, New Jersey were recently recognized by the Eat This, Not That website as the best dessert in the Garden State.

How did they come to their conclusion?

“We’ve scoured reviews, talked to locals, and even looked back on our own cross-country travels to come up with a definitive list of the best desserts across the United States”

I know what you’re thinking: what was that? Pizza? The best dessert?

Yes.

After digging I can totally see why they would honor this restaurant. Check out these amazing dessert pizzas brought to us by the family behind Brother Bruno’s.

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

This is a mixed pie made with S’Mores slices, Nutella birthday cake, fruit pebbles and Cookie Monster.

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

It sounds like a Jersey kid’s fever dream. Imagine if this was what your pizza night was like when you were younger?

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

Fans of The Parent Trap remake know there’s no other way to eat Oreos than with peanut butter. Now imagine enjoying this treat with Reese’s Chunks and Nutella Drizzle.

I can see you drooling through the screen.

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

Personally, I’m conflicted with pistachios ending up in desserts, but I’m not going to stop you from enjoying them if that’s your thing.

This slice has candied walnut glaze, pistachio spread and even more Nutella.

*Voice of Homer Simpson* “Mmmmmmmmm Nutella”

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

Back to the concept of pizza parties as a kid, imagine if that slice of birthday cake was both your pizza and your cake? Talk about two birds, one stone.

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

Am I dead and ascended to heaven?

Not better. I went to Brother Bruno and there is even more Nutella to be had.

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

For my money, there is no better combination than Nutella, pretzels and peanut butter. Now it’s on a pizza.

#Blessed

It’s not just a dessert pizza, they also do other “regular” slices. Brother Bruno’s pizza is so popular they ship it nationwide.

Orders placed on weekdays before 12 p.m. will arrive the next day! Place your order at BrotherBrunoPizza.com.

Are you feeling particularly festive? Check out some of their holiday themed pies.

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

brotherbrunopizzadeliandbagel via Instagram

I don’t know if you’re buying, I know where I’m going next time I’m in Wayne.

Looking to expand your pizza palate? Learn from the expert.

All the NJ Pizza Restaurants Barstool’s Dave Portnoy Reviewed

Dave Portnoy, commonly known as El Presidente, is the founder of Barstool Sports. Somewhere along the way, he decided to start reviewing local pizzerias, and the concept took off. Here are all the New Jersey pizzerias Dave has stopped at, and how he rated them.

The above post reflects the thoughts and observations of Kylie Moore of New Jersey 101.5. All opinions expressed are those of Kylie. You can follow Kylie on Instagram.

Click here to contact an editor about a comment or correction for this story.

Discover the must-see roads in each state

Netflix’s Most Popular TV Shows

These are the most popular TV shows ever to air on Netflix, based on hours watched during their first 28 days on air.

Comments are closed.